3DPlink Company News

3D Printing Showdown: PolyJet vs. FDM - Unveiling Precision & Durability

The Duel of 3D Printing Technologies: PolyJet vs. FDM - Unmasking the Art behind Precision and Durability

Introduction

3D printing technology has revolutionized various industries, enabling the creation of intricate and complex objects with remarkable precision. This transformative process allows for the fabrication of three-dimensional objects directly from a digital model, eliminating the need for traditional manufacturing techniques. The advancements in 3D printing have given rise to numerous printing methods, each with its own unique attributes and applications.


The Fascinating World of 3D Printing

 

Imagine a world where physical objects can be effortlessly produced from digital designs. This is the essence of 3D printing - a groundbreaking technology that facilitates the translation of virtual concepts into tangible reality.

By layering materials incrementally, 3D printers have the power to construct intricate structures that were once only imaginable. In this article, we delve into two prominent 3D printing technologies - PolyJet and Fused Deposition Modeling (FDM).

Both methodologies have gained significant traction in diverse industries due to their distinct advantages and capabilities. Understanding these technologies is crucial for those seeking efficient means of fabricating three-dimensional objects with exceptional quality.

 

Brief Overview of 3D Printing Technology

 

Before delving into PolyJet and FDM, it is important to grasp the fundamentals of 3D printing as a whole. At its core, 3D printing involves the layer-by-layer construction of an object using digital design data as a blueprint. This additive manufacturing process eliminates many limitations associated with traditional subtractive methods by building models layer upon layer until completion.

One key aspect that distinguishes various 3D printing technologies is their material deposition approach. While some techniques utilize liquid resins or powders that are solidified through chemical reactions or heat exposure, others employ filament extrusion where thermoplastic materials are melted and then precisely deposited onto a build platform.

 

Introduction to PolyJet and Fused Deposition Modeling (FDM)

 

PolyJet, pioneered by the renowned manufacturer Stratasys, is a cutting-edge technology that utilizes inkjet-like printheads to deposit layers of photopolymer materials. These liquid resins are instantaneously cured using ultraviolet light, resulting in durable and high-resolution printed objects. The PolyJet process allows for the simultaneous printing of multiple materials with varying properties, making it highly versatile for creating complex geometries.
 

Stratasys Polyjet Stratasys FDM  


In contrast, Fused Deposition Modeling (FDM), also offered by Stratasys but widely available across different brands, relies on thermoplastic filaments that are heated until molten and extruded through a nozzle. As the material cools down rapidly after deposition, it solidifies into a strong and durable structure layer by layer.

FDM is lauded for its cost-effectiveness and robustness in producing functional parts with good mechanical strength. Now that we have laid the groundwork with an overview of 3D printing technology as well as introduced PolyJet and FDM methodologies, let us dive deeper into each technique to understand their unique characteristics and applications.

 

 

Understanding PolyJet Technology

The Art of Precision and Versatility

 

PolyJet technology, pioneered by Stratasys, is a cutting-edge 3D printing technique that unleashes creativity with remarkable precision and versatility. In the realm of additive manufacturing, PolyJet stands out as a revolutionary process that enables the creation of intricate models and prototypes in astonishing detail.

At its core, the PolyJet printing process involves the layer-by-layer deposition of liquid photopolymer materials. This inkjet-like approach utilizes multiple print heads to simultaneously deposit and cure the materials, allowing for swift production while maintaining exceptional accuracy.

Each layer is precisely deposited onto a build tray and instantly cured using ultraviolet (UV) light. This ensures immediate solidification and perfect alignment with the digital design specifications.

Mastering Complexity with Multimaterial Magic

 

One of the standout advantages of PolyJet technology lies in its ability to print multiple materials with varying properties in a single print job. This opens up a world of possibilities for designers and engineers who seek to bring their wildest imaginations to life.

Whether it's combining rigid and flexible components or incorporating clear elements into complex geometries, polyjet materials offer unrivaled versatility. The wide range of available materials for PolyJet printing encompasses an impressive array of options.

 

Transparent resin printing Soft and hard resin combined printing Mixed print with clear and white resin



From rubber-like substances that mimic elastomers to transparent materials that replicate glass or PMMA, there is no shortage of choices when it comes to selecting the perfect material for your project. Stratasys' portfolio includes diverse selections such as VeroFlex, TangoPlus, and Digital ABS among others.

With these options at your disposal, you can effortlessly achieve the desired aesthetic appearance while ensuring functional integrity. In addition to its material capabilities, PolyJet technology also boasts an extraordinary smooth surface finish which enhances both tactile appeal and visual aesthetics.

The layers are seamlessly blended together during deposition due to the liquid nature of the photopolymer materials. Consequently, this eliminates the visible layer lines often associated with other 3D printing technologies like industrial FDM printers, ensuring a polished and refined final product.

 

 

Exploring Fused Deposition Modeling (FDM)

Understanding the FDM Printing Process

 

The Fused Deposition Modeling (FDM) printing process is an extrusion-based method that utilizes thermoplastic filaments to create three-dimensional objects. This technology works by melting and depositing successive layers of the filament material to build the desired object layer by layer.

The filaments are fed through a heated nozzle, which liquefies the material, and then precisely extruded onto a build platform. During the deposition process, controlled heating and cooling mechanisms are employed to ensure proper solidification of each layer.

As each new layer is added to the previous one, it bonds together to form a cohesive structure. This layer-by-layer approach allows for intricate designs and complex geometries to be realized.

Industrial FDM prints complex parts

Advantages of FDM Technology

 

One of the primary advantages of FDM technology lies in its cost-effectiveness compared to other 3D printing technologies. The lower material costs associated with thermoplastic filaments make it an attractive option for both small-scale projects and large-scale production runs.

Additionally, due to its widespread adoption in industries such as automotive, aerospace, and consumer goods, there is a plethora of filament materials available for use with FDM printers. This extensive range includes various colors, mechanical properties such as strength or flexibility, as well as specialty materials like conductive or flame-retardant filaments.

Furthermore, FDM technology boasts robustness in producing functional parts that exhibit good strength and durability. Industrial-grade FDM printers from manufacturers like Stratasys provide high-quality results suitable for end-use applications across industries.

These printers offer precise control over parameters such as temperature, speed, and infill density that enhance part performance and reliability. Exploring fused deposition modeling (FDM) reveals its extrusion-based method using thermoplastic filaments, where layer-by-layer deposition and controlled heating and cooling techniques solidify each layer.

FDM technology offers cost-effectiveness, a wide variety of filament materials, and robustness in producing functional parts. These advantages make it a desirable choice for both prototyping and manufacturing applications in diverse industries.

 

 

Comparing PolyJet vs FDM Technologies

Surface Finish

The surface finish is another crucial aspect when comparing PolyJet and FDM technologies. With its ability to deposit ultra-thin layers of liquid photopolymer materials, PolyJet excels at producing smooth surfaces on printed objects. Each layer cures immediately upon contact with UV light, allowing for seamless integration between neighboring layers.

This results in visually appealing parts with minimal visible stair-stepping or roughness. In contrast, FDM printing can result in surfaces that are slightly rougher compared to their PolyJet counterparts.

The extrusion-based nature of FDM involves building up layers by extruding molten thermoplastic materials through a nozzle onto the print bed. While modern industrial-grade FDM printers have improved surface quality significantly over consumer-grade models, some degree of texture may still be present due to the layer-by-layer deposition process.

Polyjet print FDM print

Print Quality Comparison

When it comes to print quality, PolyJet and FDM technologies exhibit distinct differences. Firstly, PolyJet offers exceptional detail resolution due to its inkjet-like approach.

The ability to deposit microscopic droplets of photopolymer material allows for the creation of intricate and highly precise designs. This results in smooth curves, sharp edges, and excellent dimensional accuracy that can be particularly advantageous for applications such as prototyping and jewelry design.

On the other hand, FDM technology may exhibit visible layer lines on the printed object's surface. This is due to the layer-by-layer deposition of thermoplastic filaments that solidify through controlled heating and cooling processes.

While innovative advancements have reduced these imperfections over time, achieving the same level of detail as PolyJet remains a challenge with FDM printers. However, it is important to note that these layer lines are often acceptable in functional prototypes or parts where aesthetics are not a primary concern.When it comes to a considering point, a professional post-processing team can achieve its smooth surfaces by sanding or painting.

 

Conclusion

 

Both PolyJet and FDM technologies offer unique advantages in the 3D printing landscape. PolyJet stands out with its superior detail resolution and ability to produce exceptionally smooth surfaces, making it an ideal choice for applications where aesthetics are paramount.

On the other hand, FDM technology offers cost-effectiveness, a wide range of available filament materials, and robustness in producing functional parts. Whether you choose polyjet printing using Stratasys PolyJet technology or opt for an industrial FDM printer from Stratasys, both technologies have their place in the additive manufacturing realm.

The key is to carefully consider your specific requirements and priorities when selecting the right 3D printing technology for your project. With continuous advancements being made in both PolyJet and FDM materials and printers, the future holds even more exciting possibilities for pushing the boundaries of what can be achieved through 3D printing.